Reliable Historical Sources Essay - 2754 Words

Reliable Historical Sources History is the study of the past, of what had really happened and who were involved. To study history itself, it is essential that the source from which the information were taken is factual as well as reliable. It is not acceptable if it contains errors and flaws or mixing the truth with some fictions. This essay will investigate and evaluate a piece of historical evidence, the Hollywood movie The Patriot starred by Mel Gibson and Heath Ledger in order to determine whether or not it is reliable and could be used to determine the events that really had happened during the American fight†¦show more content†¦A secondary source, however, offers an easier interpretation of what was stated in a primary source. An example of a secondary source is an encyclopedia telling about what happened during the Revolution for Independence in America. The disadvantage is t hat it is not one hundred percent reliable. Since The Patriot is a secondary source, it certainly contains bias and therefore makes it quite hard for the audience to be sure of its reliability. The Patriot was made for the sake of Hollywood and not to share what happened in the American history through a thorough and complete documentation. Therefore, the script The Patriot itself will certainly reflects on how the scriptwriter think about the events and contains personal opinions on the subject. Relating to the point that had just been made, the reliability of a historical source also depend on the bias a source contained. What needs to be questioned is whether or not this movie is biased? As seen from an audience perspective, The Patriot is a biased movie because once again, it is a Hollywood movie with American crews and therefore they have their own ideas on how the events had occurred and why they thought they were right in pursuing independence rather that keeping peace with the Great Britain. If seen from the British perspective, the characters on the British side might not be that bad, especially TavingtonShow MoreRelatedAre the Stories from the Holocaust Survivors with PTSD Reliable as Historical Sources?1846 Words   |  8 PagesThis investigation will answer the question To what extent are the stories from the Holocaust survivors with PTSD reliable as historical sources? This question is important because there are still holocaust survivors alive today, and their stories are arguably the ones that teach us he most about the Holocaust, since they are primary sources of the event. The survivors dealt with a lot of physical and emotional trauma while in the camps, so it would be easy for them to procure PTSD. The mentalRead MoreIntroduction. The Bible Is One Of The Bestselling Books1139 Words   |  5 PagesINTRODUCTION The Bible is one of the bestselling books in the world, for this reason it is incredibly important for Christians and non-Christians alike to examine the reliability of the text. Because the nature of this paper is rather short, the historical evidence outlined will be brief and not all-inclusive. This paper will examine the writings and thoughts of many great people including Joshua McDowell, J. Walter Wallace and William Craig. For the purpose of clarity when discussing the Bible orRead MoreThe Knowledge Of Natural Sciences And History1592 Words   |  7 Pagesin a particular Area of knowing. The statement implies that not using a network of WOK to gain knowledge is unwise. Thus, I wish to examine how we best acquire knowledge in Natural Sciences and History. My two central knowledge questions are, how reliable is it to use only one way of knowing in one Area of knowledge in order to gain knowledge? and Is it essential to use a network of ways of knowing to acquire good knowledg e? The scope of Natural Sciences is to create principles, theories and lawsRead MoreOral Tradition And Oral Traditions1272 Words   |  6 Pagesthe stories get forgotten, left out, or embellished. With each re-telling the story gets further and further away from the original. Oral tradition is a primary way of conveying culture and is a way of life in African history. Oral traditions are historical traditions passed down by word of mouth from one generation to another without written instruction. Oral tradition was used during a time period where hardly any written documents were used to document about the African people. The majority ofRead MoreImpact Of International Communications On Public Safety894 Words   |  4 Pagesamong the first means of major international trade and communication (Bulliet, Crossley, Headrick, Hirsch, Johnson, Northrup, 2005). The aforementioned authors, writer of the Houghton Mifflin Company textbook, The Earth and Its Peoples, are reliable sources as the textbook company has proven to provide students with unbiased textbooks with historically accurate content. Houghton Mifflin is a widely renowned company, currently serving nearly 50 million classrooms worldwide. Such routes proved toRead MoreAnalyzing The Four Criteria Of Authenticity877 Words   |  4 Pages Question #2 List and describe the four criteria of authenticity according to the textbook. The historical Jesus Research according to the textbook shows four criteria of Authenticity and they are the following listed below: (Page 152) The Criterion of Multiple Attestation: This criterion simply states that the material about Jesus is probably independent ancient sources. The Criterion of Palestinian Environment: In this criterion a section of material in the Gospels is probably authenticRead MorePerspective And Perception Of An Event1619 Words   |  7 Pagesaccount of an event than another, solely based on their emotions or involvement from the event. Perspective is a particular attitude or view toward an event. This is mostly facts about the event, and is what is written down or recorded in texts or historical sources. My first interviewee was my teacher Angelica Ramos. Her father was in the United States Air Force, while her mother was in Vietnam. To her, the Vietnam War was so controversial because her mother was Vietnamese and she was coming to AmericaRead MoreRelationship Between The Nobility And The Peasants1480 Words   |  6 PagesSource 6 Esther English Social Structure in the Early 18th Century. www4.wittenberg.edu/academics/hist/crom/brit/socstruc.html . N.p., n.d. Web. 28 Jan. 2016 The relationship between the nobility and the peasants is that one group is at the top, while the other is at the bottom. The nobility or gentry, were the dukes, marquesses, earls, viscounts and barons, of which there were about 180 in the early century. These were men who sat in the House of Lords by hereditary right. They lived in wealthRead MoreBernal Diaz Del Castillo Essay1258 Words   |  6 PagesEuropeans to experience the Aztec empire at its height and to visit Tenochtitlan prior to its downfall. In an era where personal accounts of the historical occurrences are almost nonexistent, Bernal Diaz’s The True History of the Conquest of New Spain provides virtually the only window into this period. As a result, his text has become the most significant historical document concerning the Spanish conquest of Mexico. Perhaps the most poignant excerpt from The True History of the Conquest of New Spain isRead MoreMark D. Roberts s Can We Trust The Gospels?967 Words   |  4 P agessome nonbelievers question the accuracy of recorded events within the Holy Bible, specifically the Gospels. Individuals debate the issue if the Gospels are historically reliable, claiming there is no tangible evidence and the books contradict themselves. Mark D. Roberts, in his book, Can we Trust the Gospels? was able to provide reliable evidence and reasons on why people can trust the Gospels. His book gives an overview on the subject of the gospel reliability and trustworthiness. Mark D. Roberts begins